Microsoft SharePoint has been a large element in the working lives of many online professionals and I’m certain there is much more to come. A myriad of conferences, consultants, books, articles and blogs have entered the stage, all with a mission to “help us make the most of the important platform”. My impression is, however that SharePoint is still surrounded by confusion. What is SharePoint really?
The below quotes by individuals with a close working knowledge of SharePoint have been carefully selected and should give you a broad perspective from across the spectre; Microsoft, their partners, analysts, consultants and customers. Take a look and it may just bring you a bit closer to understanding what SharePoint is.
- Who better to start this list than, Steve Ballmer, chief executive officer of Microsoft, who back in 2007 shared insights into how important SharePoint would become to Microsoft:
SharePoint is the definitive OS or platform for the middle tier
- Steve’s view is naturally important in terms of understanding SharePoint and what Microsoft’s intentions are, so he gets 2 quotes on this list. In a memorable quote from 2009 he said that SharePoint:
unleashes a suite of capabilities that dramatically improves the way people work
- Mauro Cardarelli is on my list of people to turn for SharePoint advice. He’s a co-author of several books on SharePoint and has a deep understanding of the platform. On the complex question of trying to figure out how much SharePoint costs, he’s said:
It requires thorough planning if you want to get to an accurate budget figure. Think it through, have a plan; more importantly, have a roadmap!
- Up next is Shawn Shell, a frequent and popular speaker at the J. Boye conferences and one of the consultants that knows SharePoint best. He recently wrote:
As Microsoft evolves the SharePoint platform, it has become an indispensable tool in many organizations
- To really understand SharePoint, let us also look at the key analysts, starting with Forrester who has not been entirely positive:
point solutions will represent a better option for buyers looking to preserve existing investments or to add a single workload, like social tools
- Industry analysts Gartner says that SharePoint is not perfect for large enterprises:
Adoption may be hindered somewhat by current economic conditions, in which many CIOs are watching their budgets carefully. Also, MSS 2010 requires 64 bit versions of SQL and Windows Server. Some high-end needs still remain unmet by MSS 2010
- Real Story Group, formerly known as CMS Watch, a vendor-neutral analyst firm, received a fair deal of publicity when they released a press release explaining how SharePoint can lead to rampant, viral proliferation and instances of uncontrolled content, as well as major compliancy risks. The headline was simply:
SharePoint is an ECM virus
- UK intranet expert Martin White has spend much of 2010 getting to understand SharePoint better and says that:
With power comes complexity, and any organisation that thought that a more robust version of MOSS07 would need less governance is going to have to reconsider its approach
- New Zealand-based Michael Sampson is an expert on collaboration which is generally perceived as a key strength for SharePoint. Still, Michael shares this honest key insight:
Microsoft SharePoint has taken the market by storm, but the embrace of the technology has run ahead of the business and human factors thinking required to make it work. For many organizations, SharePoint has become a chaotic nightmare
- Last, but not least, this list of quotes would not be complete without the voice of the customer. Mark Morrell, the prolific BT intranet manager, has blogged a fair bit about SharePoint. This one quote will help you avoid confusion even though Microsoft insists on coming up with their own terminology:
I realise that terms I used to use for other publishing tools like ‘template’ have a different meaning when I talk about SP 2010.
What is your favourite SharePoint quote?
Mark Morrell November 23rd, 2010 18:10
Hi Janus,
Thanks for the quote and link. I hope you are well and relaxing after Aarhus 10.
Just to say I expect to blog a lot more about how BT is rolling out SharePoint 2010 to make sharing knowledge easier for everyone.
It’s been a good, sometimes ‘interesting’, journey so far.
Mark
Jed November 23rd, 2010 18:10
Well I would pick the Real Story Group as my favorite one, but I don’t count SharePoint as ECM, unless that standards for “everyone’s content mangled”
Having worked with MOSS 2007 day in and day out for the last 2 years, in very different environments, I would have to hark back to those anti-drug messages from the 1980′s and say mine is “just say no” !
Jim Duncan November 23rd, 2010 18:10
I must confess I am a huge fan of SharePoint.
Mine would be “If you aren’t loving SharePoint, you might be doing it wrong.”
BJ Cattle December 1st, 2010 18:10
My favorite SharePoint Quote (I can’t remember where I first heard it):
“SharePoint does poorly what no other software can do at all.”
Ted Carroll December 1st, 2010 18:10
It makes sense that there is such a wide range of quotes on what SharePoint is, because there is an equally wide range of ways that SharePoint could be deployed.
Deploying vanilla SharePoint with no governance and poor existing information management practices would definitely be in “virus” territory – in the same way that many Lotus Notes deployments led to hundreds of dis-organised silos of information.
The virus jibe should also be put into context with the history of deployment of the traditional “ECM products” – few of which achieved enterprise-wide usage. SharePoint has a much better chance of enterprise-wide deployment because it is relatively easy to use.
However, vanilla SharePoint only goes so far when solving business problems, There are many situations where the best way to deploy SharePoint is through business-focused point solutions – and SharePoint 2010 is a hugely rich and easy to develop platform for these. These will not suffer the proliferation problem, as they will be more tightly governed – and will lead to better organised information, and (hopefully) happier users !
Kristoffer Olin December 17th, 2010 18:10
I must say that Mark Morrell wrote my favorite:
“Someone described SP 2010 as “the best sweetie shop in town” but I feel as the BT Intranet manager that I’m at the front door reminding everyone they still need to eat a healthy diet.”